[David] Good. Allen, let’s get into a conversation about technology. There’s so much going on. This could be just a whole AI segment. what’s your hearing? You said you listened to one of the AI podcasts lately. What’s your thoughts?
[Allen] I did. Yeah. It was it was with Pavan and somebody on his team. They were talking about AI and about their platform and what they’ve seen and learned, and some great information. For anyone, there, there’s a lot flooding the market about AI, and I know that we’ve talked about Pavon’s technology quite a bit on the podcast. Even if you’re not a fan of his technology or you have no interest it’s probably worth going back and listening to because they just share some generic insights that are really good to listen to. Some things are obvious, so if you’re new to what AI and underwriting and how AI fits in, it’s great to listen to, and if you’re an expert at it, but, or you’ve seen a million other solutions, it’s probably good to go listen to as well. But so I thought that was good, David. I don’t know if you have the live broadcast on replay on LinkedIn or anywhere that someone can get to, but you may wanna just mention that quickly.
[David] Yeah, go to the website. It’s there. It’s also on LinkedIn, it’s on a website. The, look at on lending website, also on YouTube. So yeah- Great … we’re getting a lot of comments on that. A lot, especially the one having to talking about the cost to originate. Most people are, Alan, are looking at it or responding with just utter disbelief when the industry average is still running anywhere $4,300 at the low end to as much as $6,500 operational cost, and then Pavon’s out there doing it for $125. And then he went through and, as you heard, went through there with Jennifer and categorically told them what their cost is. I’ve talked to Pavon since then, and he’s gonna go out and hire an accounting firm to go out and validate that so we have a third-party validation of that. And- so
[Allen] It’s not the spot that I was going to start my segment, but since you brought it up, yeah, so Sun West and Angel AI, Pavon, they claim it’s now under $125 a manufacturer loan, excluding sales, marketing, and third-party expenses. So let’s be clear on that, okay? Yeah. Better has talked up production costs below $1,000 per mortgage. That’s as per National Mortgage News or actually- … National Mortgage Professional, National, yeah … NMP. PennyMac reported a 25% drop in operational origination costs after switching to Vesta, while the MBA has put the cost still above $12,000 per loan. And other people, this is just what was in the news, other people are seeing savings, but we have to be very careful, David, ’cause some people are saying there’s a savings, but the savings doesn’t represent the cost or getting what, when do you get the ROI and how do you separate the cost? And it depends if how your accounting works, it depends how you look at your P&L, it depends how you, if you have a true technology group. Some people have a separate P&L or a separate division that’s the technology group, and they can write off software, the cost of building software over many years. So all of that depends. There’s a lot of factors in the middle there. But yes, some people are getting a savings True. Very good point. Thank you. Before I get into technology, let’s talk about alligators, ‘ cause that’s always fun. You’re in Florida, that works. So imagine this you work at a bagel place. More specifically, you work at the Bagel Dock Express in Southport, North Carolina. On Thursday, October 29th at 3:00 in the afternoon, the shop was closed and a gentleman, his name is Jesse Driscoll, he’s the owner, he was installing a new oven. I don’t know how many people this has ever happened to. Anyways, the back door was left open while he was doing it, and a three-foot alligator walked right in through the back. Security video showed it crossing the stockroom and the kitchen and stopping at the front counter. And he said he’d never in a million years expect to see an alligator. Called 911. They took care of it. But the funny part is the aftermath. shop posted the video set to the Pink Panther theme with the caption, “Apparently word of our fresh bagels has made its way into the swamp.” The police officer posted it as Alligator Aisle One, and there’s tons and tons of commenters and jokes about it, so it’s pretty funny. You want to check that out. That is hil- … That’s good. That’s interesting. Yeah. All right. I’m sure he needed to change his pants afterwards too. Yeah. I’m just guessing, but, hopefully the the bagels are are good there. All right. So we all were affected, David, by the Microsoft Outlook crash last week. Yep. If you weren’t, you are hiding under a rock. I did see, there’s one or two people, it’s not very common, but some people are using Google Workspace or the Google Enterprise, mostly not lenders and those people were up and running. But in general this is really funny, I saw all kinds of posts about it. I saw two very quick things I want to bring up before we get into actual mortgage news, ’cause I got a ton of great mortgage news. The first thing is I saw this post. It said, “Microsoft Outlook crashed, and the fact that people are celebrating a systems failure like it’s a national holiday says more about the workplace burnout than any employee engagement survey ever could.” Yeah. Emails did make their way through, folks, but there are scams out. Now, you may have already seen the scams. I know this was last week at the end of the week. However, if you get a message- And it says, ” Action required: some sort of messages…” And it’s got the Microsoft logo, and it’s formatted really pretty, and it says, “Action required. Some number of messages are being held. You must click here to release them.” It’s spam. Do not click that button or that link. And if you’re talking to borrowers or homeowners and you want just a way to keep in touch with them and talk to them or show them that, you’re working on their behalf, find out about this. Take exactly what I said and put in Microsoft Outlook outage scams, and put together an email. Have GPT help you put together an email, and send it to your customers. And just, help them be on the lookout. This is an important financial transaction that they’re all involved in, and it’s good for you to do these services, these acts of kindness on their behalf. So with that being said, David, let’s get to some mortgage news. There’s a lot of really good stuff. check this out. UWM is paying their brokers to use their software. So it’s called UWM’s 40 to the Finish. It gives 40 basis points better in pricing through the end of the year on new locks starting November 11th for borrowers with 700-plus scores if the broker uses Underwriting Plus, Track Plus, or Virtual Closing. That’s $1,600 on a 400K loan. That was in National Mortgage Professional News. Ishbia calls it a strategic way to handle this. “The price goes to brokers who use our software.” And I thought that was very cool. Next piece. It’s… By the way, it’s not that no one’s ever said, “Use our technology and get better pricing,” it’s the marketing, folks, and it’s, a way to push that these new tools to be used by brokers and to continue brokers to bring them more loans and keep coming back. Better. We all know who Better is. They just replaced management layers with AI agents. So on their earnings call, they just signed 39 brokerage to it, what they call their 10 million AI platform, with 57% of their loan volume coming through it. And they terminated… terminated’s such a bad word, right? Let’s just say they helped make successful somewhere else a VP, a director in senior management roles in favor not in favor of AI agents, it’s targeting a 40% expense, total expense cut by the end of Q4. And they said that they’re also coming off a costly leadership fight, so watch for the results they’re citing. And then get this. Here is a survey, David. So JD Power, they do a lot of great surveys. This is a generic one, meaning not from someone in the mortgage industry. This is 50-50, split down the middle, but it’s not a surprise, but the numbers have risen. I’ll tell you what it is. It’s called digital is up, communication is down. Overall satisfaction is unchanged at 760, whatever the 760 represents. But what they’re saying is two-thirds of Gen Y and Gen Z borrowers prefer self-service, yet 49% say the representative should have been more involved. Check that out. I’m gonna repeat that. Two-thirds of Gen Y and Gen Z, they want self-service, but of those two-thirds, 49% said a representative should have been more involved So I guess they wanna eat their right? That’s their cake they’re eating too, isn’t it? Yeah. Yeah. Chase led, by the way, a lot of those points and banks held the top spot for a second year, and I thought that was interesting. Two more, two more quick things. I’ve got so many funny things here. Check this one out. This is a database that was built for AI assistants to recommend loan officers. So MCP folks, you can go in Claude, you can go in Gemini, you can go into GPT, whatever you want, and you can look for lenddb.ai. So that’s L-E-N and then db.ai. There’s not two Ds in there, so it’s L-E-N-D-B.A-I. They launch November 5th. It’s free. They have a quarter million US loan officer records, and it’s free. If you go through their MCP server for assistants like GPT, Claude, and you can be matched by location, licensing specialty, and language. So the founders that put this out there, they pitch it as a pay to rank lead list. And what basically you can do is you can say, “Hey, I am in California, and I’m looking for a Spanish-speaking originator who deals with two-family homes.” And it will generate through Claude, GPT, whatever, and find that for you. So there’s a lot of other ways you can use it. You can’t use it to find people you wanna market to, so for the technology vendors listening to this, that you can’t do. There’s other things you can do for that. But lenddb.ai, brand new. And then David, this is actually really interesting. In the world of maintaining relationships and trying to keep our borrowers connected to us, right? ‘Cause in mortgage it’s very hard to maintain the relationship beyond the closing. NewRes, they just added personal loans through Upgrade. And basically on November 12th, NewRes launched what they call NewRes Personal Loans. It’s powered by Upgrade for eligible NewRes homeowners with funding in as little one, as little as one business day. And what they do, Upgrade will originate and service the loans. It’s issued by their bank partner. And in NewRes’ example, they’re saying a $6,500 card balance, so this is for their borrowers that are being serviced. A $6,500 card balance repaid with a three-year loan at 12.41% versus 19% on a typical card is a savings of at least $218 a month. And what NewRes and Upgrade are saying is it builds on a $1.5 billion loan investment between Rhythm Capital and Upgrade. So there are unique ways and relationships that are happening out there in order to facilitate more connection and lifetime relationship with your customers. Interesting. Very creative. Very good, Alan I just saw David Kittle just raised his hand. I think he either has a joke about an alligator or he wanted to say something about NuRisk
[Kittle] I wanna say something about AI, if I can inject it here just a little bit. Alan, maybe before you got on and this is gonna be in your ballpark, and Alice as well since we went over a lot of branches. But we just had a terrible ATC shutdown which affected most of the world over about 48-hour period For the non-pilots- Yeah … ATC- Air traffic control, sorry. Yeah Thank you … the glitch. Thank you very much. It brings to mind my wife writes the BCP plans for First American Mortgage Solutions. And, BCP, we’re talking in those yeah The business continuity plans Thank you Make sure that f- for those lenders who have your GSE approvals, you know what that is ’cause you’re required to have it. A lot of them are for other things as well. But make sure they’re in place, make sure they’re up to date. And just to get your thoughts on what could happen on local or different kinds of disasters that affects the technology today, Allen. And then have Alice jump in here as well
[David] The closing on the sale of my home was delayed by one day because of that whole thing. So one day isn’t a huge lot, but it was inconvenience. And again, over the interest, over the weekend that it cost me. So yeah, Allen, go ahead.
[Allen] Yeah. Yeah it’s absolutely interesting. Number one is AI has not made its way into business continuity plans in general, and I think we talk about that each week. I just didn’t want to sound like a broken record, ‘ cause I feel every week we say the same thing about, understanding your vendors and the tools we’re using and the technology and AI and all that. But yeah I’d be very curious in the end to really know what has happened and what the business continuity plan was. There’s so many reports, more specifically about exactly what happened with air traffic control, David. There was a whole bunch of reports that said they had a system that they fell back to. So the risk mitigation was that they went to an old analog system that hasn’t been used in 20-plus years or something. Other people are saying that software updates and patches, and as lenders, we should not be allowing our vendors to do technology upgrades and software patches, especially on a Friday before a weekend, but in the middle of the day. The software tech world in mortgage typically does things on Tuesday nights because you still have part of the week, or sometimes on Thursday nights ’cause Fridays are slow. But nonetheless there’s a lot of reports of people stating that they didn’t understand, it wasn’t an outage, it was an outage. But in the end, technology is gonna continue to break and the severity of the break is gonna become more impactful and worse. So now imagine your financial institution having a number of transactions that are stuck or having information that’s invalid or AI that screwed something up. So we gotta be really careful that we’ve got the backup, the belt and suspenders approach, and we’re always verifying information. I know I’m going on too far to your answer, David but it’s such a great point and lenders have to have the risk mitigation and this plan in place.
[David] Alice, you wrote a policy on this, so will you talk about what you’ve done in this, this work you’ve done in this area, business continuation?
[Alice] Yeah, as MortgageU, we did a lot of this. And also at Union Home, one of the things that we did was as part of annual training that our leadership teams would go through, and even the up-and-coming team leads, we would get them involved in mock disasters. So do this all as a group. You design the case studies. In a couple of cases, we would actually surprise them that they didn’t know it was coming. So that was another part of it. They thought they were coming to another type of seminar and gonna sit and listen to somebody, and voila, we pull this out and scare them that, okay, this is a real event. Like Fannie and Freddie go out of business overnight, right? You think of some outrageous things, like David, your example of what was that? The building’s on fire and the- Yeah, we had the- … fireproof cabinets. What was that story?
[David] Yeah, what happened in one of our offices is we had a file servers in that particular building, and there was an escrow company above our file storage or where we had our servers. And over the weekend, the escrow company caught on fire and burned a hole and weakened the structure. So all the fireproof file cabinets where they were storing all the notes and all the deeds, the things they had to hold onto legally fell through the roof and absolutely came down, destroyed, crushed, burned, scorched. You can… You add more compounding… any more-
[Alice] They’re completely annihilated. Annihilated. There’s nothing to save. Truly. But, and we didn’t have business continuation. That was back in the earliest days. This was 30 years ago. And, Yeah … that certain… so Dave. So you ha-
[Alice] So what you do is you create the scenarios of the impossible thing- Yeah is happening, and give your team the opportunity to come up with what are the solutions. Are they able to think of all the things that have to come into play when different disasters happen?
[Bill] Yeah, and so Dave, in your scenario in the first World Trade Center bombing, right? Yes. The traders, Cantor Fitzgerald, went into the restaurant, cafeteria area to get the knives to use as screwdrivers to take their computers apart so that when they walked down the 100-plus stories, they had their hard drives in their pocket. That was disaster planning on the fly. Wow. And- Wow … and the other thing now that I challenge folks is, ‘ cause folks are used to, and Alice referenced it, you’re used to having a BCP plan book, literally a book. To me, the exercise now is because you can’t prep for everything, what’s your plan and structure to first communicate and then be able- Yeah to think and adapt on the fly? Yep.
[Allen] Yeah, these are- And thinking about the people first. Where we found that the teams were really very good at. what are you gonna do for your people first? Communication with the customer, Alice? Yeah, the communication. Your employees. Oh. Then the customers. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
[Kittle] So, Dave, back to, if we’re talking about flying for a second, business continuity plan, your BCP plan in the cockpit is A and C, aviate, navigate, and communicate, in those orders. Yeah. So if you have an emergency in the cockpit, you’ve gotta have something, to Bill’s point, the more technology we have in place, whether it’s AI or not at this point- the more vulnerable your business is to getting shut down or getting affected. And you really need plans in place, and your staff needs to know what that is. I think, Alice, when we talked pre-podcast today, you were talking about when you did it, you can opine on this better than I can, but you actually ran tests in your branches. And a really good thing to do.
[Alice] That they can actually execute, and then they all had a handout by their desks, too, to make them think about if it actually happened, who do I call? And then you go wait a minute, what if I don’t have a telephone? What if cell lines are down?” What? You have to walk through all the what-ifs.
[Allen] David, this is all this is stuff that people forget about or people when they’ve had staff disappear, meaning become successful somewhere else, or they’ve had to make changes, that they overlook This is actually… I’m gonna talk about this next week in a little more detail, but this is a really great topic. I’m happy you brought this up, David, and I think next week is a really good time for us to to get into some more details. Good. Look forward to it. Yeah, I think we should.
[David] I think it’s one of those things, I think we’ve got our good friend, Mr. Kiddle, that does AML AN- money laundering. He does a brilliant job, and we’re gonna be having him on again talking about this. Because I had a friend of mine his controller wired out thinking wiring it to a supplier, that’s- he’s a manufacturer, wired out $187,000 to a false number. And they got scammed, and he just didn’t have the proper procedures. And so if you do have that, there is literally moments Bob will tell you, when Bob Simpson, when we have him on talking about this, you have literally moments before that money is most likely gone from the bank that it was wired to. It’s gone, and you only have moments to respond. And it’s the AML it’s the procedures for disaster recovery, and it can go in so many different directions. So good. Alan, I applaud that. Let’s do that and focus some more in on some of these things, because I don’t think it’s gonna be getting less. It’s gonna be getting more common, sadly. It’s the state of our, it’s a state of our industry, a state of our world that we’re in right now. Good job.
Allen Pollack
, Chief Operating Officer, Tech Consultant
Allen Pollack, a Mortgage & Financial Services Technology Advisor, is a subject matter expert in the mortgage origination process along with software product management and software development.
In today’s financial services push to all things Digital, Allen has been helping lenders and financial services solution providers align their digital transformation and technology strategies by removing the human element of risk, and automating processes that drive efficiencies and margins into profits.
Over the course of his career, Allen has co-created and developed technology business models that have birthed highly successful, innovative solutions and companies.
Allen co-founded and served as CTO of New York Loan Exchange (NYLX), a loan product eligibility and pricing engine (PPE) that made an immediate impact on the industry, scaling the company quickly and forming partnerships with multiple mortgage and financial lending companies. In 2012, Allen was a co-founder of a merger between NYLX and Aklero Risk Analytics that created LoanLogics, A Mortgage Loan Quality and Performance Analytics company. Allen served as CTO where he continued to bring new and innovative product solutions to the market that made a significant impact to mortgage lenders that reduced risk, scaled business channels, and grew profits in a very competitive and highly regulated market.
Allen is also is mortgage and finance technology contributor on a weekly live industry podcast, Lykken on Lending, and is launching a new podcast soon to be released, TechStack Radio, dedicated to technology and innovation in Financial Services.